The disparity in message between Haggai and earlier prophets – Haggai being a more practical book with more modest aims and a relatively upbeat message – is reinforced by another key distinction: the people actually obey Haggai's prophecy! From the Nevi’im Rishonim to nearly all the prophets of Trei Asar, the prophets’ messages are almost universally disregarded by their audiences. The exception that proves the rule is, of course, Yona, who is obeyed by none other than the people of Ninveh. Arguably, the two major differences between Haggai and other prophets – the nature of his message and the people’s response – are closely connected. Precisely because Haggai's message was more specific and optimistic, less radical and cataclysmic, his message was more readily embraced by the people than the doomsday scenarios prognosticated by his predecessors.
Read the full article here