Vayishlach: Who was In the Right? Inconclusive Messages

In this shiur, we analyze the story of Dina, Shimon, Levi, and Yaakov. Were Shimon and Levi in the wrong, or was Yaakov? What should have been the response of Yaakov to his sons actions at Shechem? These are two major approaches, but we seek to demonstrate that the parasha itself is inconclusive. Both sides have points, and each argument has elements that can be supported in the text. We grapple with the competing issues of zealotry vs. Hillul Hashem.  

What we can concluded is that when we are in difficult moral situations. We must carefully evaluate our actions and verify that we are not motivated by the wrong things and that the actions we are taking are moral, and hope that we have God’s help in making the right decision.